15 Best Restaurants in New Buffalo, MI

New Buffalo, MI, is a popular destination for residents, seasonal homeowners, and visitors seeking a convenient escape near Lake Michigan. Its growing food scene offers a range of casual eateries, craft breweries, and refined dining spots. Whether you're visiting for the weekend or considering a permanent move, exploring the best restaurants in New Buffalo is a great way to experience the area’s local flavor. Below is a guide to 15 restaurants that represent a wide variety of cuisines and dining styles, offering something for every palate.

A New Buffalo staple, The Stray Dog Bar & Grill offers a relaxed environment with indoor and rooftop seating. The menu includes American bar food such as burgers, sandwiches, and salads, alongside a full bar with local craft beer. Its location near the harbor makes it a convenient stop for boaters and beachgoers. This restaurant is particularly busy in the summer months, so early arrival is recommended.

PostBoy brings a modern approach to casual dining with a concise menu built around seasonal ingredients. The restaurant’s minimalist decor is matched by its elevated comfort food options, offering items like fried chicken sandwiches, fresh salads, and rotating specials. It’s a newer addition to the downtown area but has quickly gained traction with both locals and weekenders. Their commitment to quality ingredients sets them apart in the local food scene.

This long-established Italian restaurant offers a mix of classic and contemporary dishes. Guests can expect options like house-made pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and an extensive wine list. Brewster’s also has a sizable outdoor patio, making it a good choice for summer dining. It remains a popular destination for both dinner service and weekend brunch.

The False Front is a bar-forward restaurant that focuses on locally sourced ingredients and inventive cocktails. While its atmosphere is casual, the menu leans upscale, with a selection of creative small plates and well-executed mains. It's an ideal spot for those seeking a more intimate dining experience. The rotating menu keeps repeat visits interesting for regular patrons.

Located inside The Harbor Grand Hotel, the Terrace Room offers waterfront views and a menu influenced by Italian and Mediterranean flavors. Popular items include seafood pasta, flatbreads, and an extensive cocktail list. It's a strong choice for special occasions or a quiet evening by the lake. Guests appreciate the view of the marina, especially during sunset hours.

A reliable neighborhood eatery, Casey’s offers a menu filled with American pub favorites such as wings, wraps, and burgers. It’s a laid-back spot popular with both locals and visitors. The outdoor seating area is active during warmer months, often featuring live music or seasonal events. Its long-standing presence in the community makes it a familiar go-to for casual dining.

This cocktail lounge and small-plate restaurant stands out for its curated drink menu and a rotating selection of sharable dishes. The ambiance is relaxed yet refined, making it suitable for date nights or group gatherings. The Hummingbird Lounge puts a strong focus on presentation and service.  Their bartenders are known for crafting well-balanced, house-specialty cocktails.

Sonny D’s is a no-frills, family-owned bar and grill serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Known for its friendly service and hearty portions, it’s especially popular for breakfast classics, burgers, and homemade soups. It’s a favorite among year-round residents and offers consistent quality. It’s also one of the few places in town offering early morning service during the week.

Housed in a renovated church, this brewery and restaurant serves wood-fired pizza alongside its craft beer lineup. Beer Church Brewing Co. blends historic architecture with a modern menu, offering both indoor and patio seating. Its casual vibe appeals to a wide audience. The brewery frequently hosts community events and seasonal releases.

Al Fuego brings a Latin-inspired menu to New Buffalo, offering grilled meats, tacos, and specialty cocktails. The bar is well-stocked with tequila and mezcal selections, making it a popular spot for happy hour or dinner with friends. The environment is energetic, and the service is prompt. Its bold flavors and generous portions attract diners looking for something different in the area.

Located just outside the main downtown area, Ghost Isle Brewery offers scenic views, a full dining menu, and in-house beers. Menu items range from smoked meats to sandwiches and hearty appetizers. It’s a good option for those seeking a casual meal with outdoor seating and lake views. Families and large groups will find ample space both indoors and on the patio.

Situated inside Four Winds Casino, Copper Rock Steakhouse offers classic steakhouse fare, including prime cuts, seafood, and wine pairings. The atmosphere is upscale, with attentive service and a refined menu. It caters to both casino visitors and guests seeking a more formal dining experience in the area. Reservations are encouraged due to high demand, especially on weekends.

Redamak’s is a longstanding favorite for its simple approach to classic American food—especially its cheeseburgers. Open seasonally, the restaurant draws large crowds in the summer months, thanks to its quick service and family-friendly atmosphere. It has been a tradition for many visitors to stop here on their way to or from the beach. The nostalgic diner-style experience adds to its ongoing popularity.

Located inside the Marina Grand Resort, Bentwood Tavern offers waterfront dining with a menu that combines American and international dishes. Guests can choose from options like fresh seafood, creative appetizers, and locally sourced entrees. The dining room overlooks the harbor, adding to the appeal. The restaurant is also a popular spot for brunch, with seasonal options available.

Denizas Joint is a low-key restaurant offering a blend of Mexican and American dishes. Its menu includes tacos, burritos, and burgers, making it a versatile spot for casual dining. The service is welcoming, and the prices are reasonable, making it popular with both residents and travelers. Its convenient location and broad menu make it a reliable everyday option.

Jackson Matson has earned recognition as a top-performing real estate professional throughout Southwest Michigan, including New Buffalo, MI, real estate. He consistently ranks among the top 1% of agents in the region and has received the prestigious Diamond Award for his achievements with @properties. With over 20 years of experience in the second-home market, Jackson is known for his ability to advocate strongly for his clients’ needs. His work ethic, attention to detail, and ability to communicate clearly with buyers and sellers contribute to a trusted reputation among clients and industry professionals alike.

Contact Jackson Matson today for expert advice and personalized assistance navigating the New Buffalo, MI, real estate market.